Monday, October 27, 2014

Criticism

Madiosn Reid
AP Lit
Mr. Beattie
Block E
October 27, 2014
Critical Response
I was assigned to group one with the article The Ending of the Novel by George M. Spangler. Overall the argument of the article was the ending was weak in regards that it created a change in characterization. This is because the ending was too simple for such a complex character. Spangler states “having overcome so much in the way of frustration, Edna is destroyed by so little.” This is evidence to the fact that Edna’s character deserved more than just death. It seems she went through the hardships going against society to get nothing in the end/ in return.
Another point Spangler made was that the ending was probably geared towad what society views toward the book and created the ending for the society. This pretty much means she held back to protect herself from criticism, which is similar to what happened to the character Edna. It states that the author “provided a conclusion for a novel other than the one she wrote, a conclusion for a novel much more conventional and much less interesting.”

I very much agree with this critique that the ending was disappointing and how it doesn’t match the beginning. For example Edna’s character as a whole “suddenly collapses, and what the reader gets in the way of explanation does not follow from what he has witnessed before.” This means Edna goes from an almost rebellious persona who would stand up against societies norms to submissive. , For example in the book it says “but it was too late; the shore was far behind her, and her strength was gone” (157). This doesn’t reflect the strength we saw in Edna while reading a book and makes the conclusion to the story not a very strong one. Our group even described it as taking the easy way out.

No comments:

Post a Comment